Coles and Saputo Sage Continues

Submissions to the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission, on their concerns about the proposed acquisition of Saputo milk processing plants by Coles, closed on 3 August. The ACCC currently propose to make their final findings by 14 September.

In their statement of issues published in July, ACCC raised several areas of concern. They believe it is possible that sale of the Erskine Park (NSW) facility could see significantly less competition in the market for fresh milk, in several regions of NSW, and they are also concerned at the impact on the dairy industry if Coles decides to move processing from further north, or elsewhere, to the Erskine Park facility.

eastAUSmilk has made a submission in response to the concerns raised by the ACCC, and stressed they are not trying to force Saputo to hang onto milk processing plants they don’t want, nor that Coles will harm the dairy industry recklessly. Rather, the eastAUSmilk submission stressed that the competitive advantage which would be enjoyed by Coles if they bought the plants, and the production opportunities they represent, would most likely see Coles make changes to their operations which could drastically impact markets as far north as southern Queensland.

The solutions proposed by eastAUSmilk focused on keeping competition in the NSW market for fresh milk, by encouraging Saputo to go to market with their plants, to see if other milk processors are interested, or alternatively encouraging a joint venture between Coles and another processor or attach conditions to the sale which protect competition. In all cases, eastAUSmilk urged that the Dairy Industry Code be updated to address both this proposed purchase, and any other proposals for vertical integration in the industry.

eastAUSmilk has offered to work with ACCC to develop each of these proposals, because any solution will work better if it has dairy farmer input.

Mike Smith, eastAUSmilk Government Relations Manager